I should have known this book would be a pretensious collection of self-important intellectual crap that takes the fun out of the most fun half hour on television. But I’ve been wrong before, and I was hoping that would be the case here. Nope.
I honestly didn’t make it through the whole thing — after being disgusted with the first two essays (“Homer and Aristotle” and “Lisa and American Anti-intellectualism”), I skimmed the first page or so of what remained, confirming my suspicions. I learned little beyond this: there’s no easier way to destroy comedy’s inherent goal (to make you laugh) than to analyze it in detail. From essays deconstructing various characters (we all know by now that there’s not supposed to be any continuity to The Simpsons — the characters are general molds that are customized to fit the needs of a particular episode) to one that accuses the show of not attacking Bill Clinton enough (will the Limbaughs of the world ever be satisfied?), this book reminds me of… well, a Simpsons quote. Bart and Lisa are playing a board game with Rod and Tod Flanders, who move their pieces one space at each turn rather than rolling dice. “It’s less fun that way,” they say.
One single essay (“The Simpsons and Allusion: Worst Essay Ever”) stands out among the rest on the simple virtue that its authors seem to actually get the joke. Rather than search for any deeper meaning within the actions of specific characters or situations, this piece instead explores the value of one of the show’s most powerful tools: references. The significance of The Simpsons’ cultural shorthand — both highbrow and low — is examined, without once straying into that “let’s take it apart till it stops working” mentality that seems to drive the rest of this book.
I’ve argued for years that The Simpsons contains much of intellectual value, but as most good parody shows us, there is such a thing as going too far. Be proud of yourself for laughing at the references to Ayn Rand or Jackson Pollock — but don’t be afraid to laugh when Homer falls down on his ass, either. Call me an American anti-intellectual if you must, but books like this sometimes make me glad I never finished college.